Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)

This policy is based on the principles of transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing set out by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME, on the instructions of the Iraqi Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research, and on COPE’s position statement on authorship and AI tools. It applies to authors, reviewers, editors-in-chief and editors.

1. Authors

  1. The use of generative AI tools, including large language models, is not permitted at any stage of manuscript preparation, including:
    • generating the research paper or any part of its text, including the introduction, methodology, results, discussion and conclusion;
    • designing the study, or producing or modifying figures and tables;
    • searching the literature or summarising it using these tools.
  2. AI tools may not be listed as authors, as they cannot take responsibility for the scientific work.
  3. Images generated or altered by AI are not permitted in figures that present results or data.
  4. Authors are responsible for verifying every reference. Fabricated or non-existent references are treated as a breach of research integrity.
  5. All manuscripts are screened using Turnitin, including its AI-writing indicator. If the indicator exceeds 25%, the manuscript is returned to the author for clarification, and the author is asked to explain the reason for the high percentage. The indicator alone is never the sole basis for rejection; the editor reviews each case individually.

2. Reviewers

  1. Reviewers must not upload a manuscript, or any part of it, to any generative AI tool, as this breaches the confidentiality of peer review.
  2. Reviewers must not use AI tools to evaluate the manuscript or to write the review report.
  3. Reviewers are asked to confirm in the review form that they have not used these tools.

3. Editors and Editorial Board

  1. Automated tools are used only for similarity checking and the AI-writing indicator (Turnitin). All editorial decisions, including desk rejection, reviewer selection, acceptance and rejection, are made by human editors.
  2. AI tools may not be relied on to evaluate manuscripts.

4. Breaches

Unauthorised or inappropriate use of AI is handled under the journal’s publication ethics policies on corrections, retractions and withdrawals, in line with COPE guidance. A breach may result in the rejection or withdrawal of the manuscript, and the case may be referred to the university’s publication ethics committee where appropriate.

This policy is reviewed annually.